Five More of Portland's Greatest Mistakes
Round two of Portland's regrets: the streetcars we scrapped, the freeways we built and the cast-iron blocks we turned into parking.
A while back I listed five of Portland’s biggest mistakes, and I meant what I said at the top of that one: I love this city and I think we get more decisions right than wrong.
The trouble with making a list like that is you start noticing the ones you left off. A streetcar rail showing through worn asphalt. A parking lot on First Avenue with a suspiciously handsome building on either side. Here are five more.
1. Scrapping the Original Streetcar System
A century ago you could ride a streetcar to almost any corner of Portland. The network was one of the densest in the country for a city this size, and it built the place we live in now. Sellwood, Hawthorne, Belmont, Alberta, Mississippi, St. Johns: every one of those little main streets exists because a trolley once stopped there.
Then the car arrived, ridership fell, the tracks needed expensive repairs, and buses looked like the flexible modern answer. Line after line was converted. The last city streetcars ran in 1950, and the interurban trains to Oregon City gave up in 1958.
About the General Motors story
The popular version says General Motors killed the streetcars so it could sell buses. There is something to it. GM and its partners did buy up transit companies in dozens of American cities through a firm called National City Lines, and they were convicted in federal court in 1949 over the bus supply side of that scheme.
Portland’s story is less tidy. Our system was done in mostly by local owners, thin margins and a public that was thrilled with its new automobiles. That is a duller villain, and a more uncomfortable one, since it is us.
What it cost
We have spent the decades since 1986 rebuilding rail a piece at a time, first MAX, then the modern streetcar in 2001. It is good that we did. It has also cost billions to replace a fraction of what we tore out and paved over. On some old streets you can still see the original rails surfacing through the blacktop, like a receipt.
2. Closing the Council Crest Amusement Park
This one follows from the first, because the streetcar made it possible.
Council Crest is the highest point in the city, a bit over a thousand feet. In 1907 the trolley company opened an amusement park up there to give people a reason to buy a ticket to the end of the line. It had a scenic railway, a carousel, a Ferris wheel, a dance hall and a wooden observation tower. On a clear day you paid your fare, rode up through the trees, and looked out at five volcanoes with a bag of popcorn in your hand.
It lasted until 1929. The Depression, the automobile and declining streetcar ridership finished it off, and the rides were dismantled. The tower came down in 1941.
Is this a tragedy? No. Council Crest Park is a lovely spot today, quiet and grassy, with a stone viewing circle where the crowds used to be. But Portland still has one streetcar-era amusement park, Oaks Park, down on the river in Sellwood since 1905, and it is one of the most charming things in town. A second one, perched on a hilltop above the city, would have been a pretty wonderful companion.
3. Inviting Robert Moses to Town
In 1943, with a wartime shipyard boom under way and a postwar slump expected, Portland’s leaders did what a lot of ambitious cities did. They hired Robert Moses, the New York master builder, to tell them what to construct when peace came.
It must have felt like a coup. Moses and his team spent a short stay in town and delivered a report titled Portland Improvement. Its centerpiece was a ring of freeways around downtown, with new bridges to connect it.
It took a couple of decades, but much of that sketch got poured:
- The Eastbank Freeway (I-5) took the east shore of the Willamette, cutting the inner eastside off from the water for good.
- The Stadium Freeway (I-405) was dug through the west side of downtown, wiping out some 26 blocks of older buildings and leaving the trench that still separates downtown from Goose Hollow.
- The Fremont and Marquam bridges closed the loop.
The plan did not stop there. Later highway maps descended from it called for more freeways across the city, including the Mount Hood Freeway, which would have plowed through Southeast along the Division and Clinton corridor.
That one, we stopped. Neighbors organized, the city and county withdrew support in 1974, and the federal money was redirected, a good share of it into the first MAX line. Around the same time Harbor Drive was torn up and replaced with Waterfront Park. The neighborhoods that would have been flattened are now some of the most sought-after in Portland.
So the freeway revolt is a point of pride. It just came a few miles of concrete too late for the east bank.
4. Using the Willamette as a Sewer
For most of its history Portland ran its sewage straight into the river. Even after treatment plants arrived in the 1950s, the older parts of the city kept a combined system, with stormwater and sewage sharing the same pipes. In dry weather that worked. When it rained, which you may have heard it does here, the pipes filled and the overflow went directly into the Willamette and the Columbia Slough, raw.
This happened dozens of times a year. Generations of Portlanders grew up being told, sensibly, not to touch the water.
The fix was the Big Pipe project: enormous tunnels bored under both banks of the river, big enough to drive a truck through, to hold the surge until the treatment plant can catch up. The west side tunnel opened in 2006 and the east side in 2011. All told it took about twenty years and roughly 1.4 billion dollars, and ratepayers are still seeing it on their sewer bills.
It worked. Overflows are now rare events tied to the heaviest storms, and people swim off the docks downtown in July, which would have been unthinkable in my parents’ day.
The river is not clean. The lower harbor is a federal Superfund site, thanks to a century of industry. But on the sewage question, we fixed the mistake. We just chose the slowest and most expensive way to do it, which was to wait a hundred years.
5. Bulldozing the Cast-Iron Blocks
In the 1870s and 1880s the streets along the waterfront filled with cast-iron commercial buildings: three and four story blocks with columns, arches and ornament ordered from foundry catalogs and bolted onto the front. Row after row of them lined First through Fourth Avenues.
Old buildings come down in any living city, and a balance has to be struck between keeping things and getting on with life. Here the scale tipped hard the wrong way.
The waterfront blocks went first, cleared in the early 1940s for the seawall and Harbor Drive. More went in the 1950s for bridge approaches. And a depressing number were knocked down for no project at all, just surface parking, because a lot full of cars paid better than a half-empty Victorian warehouse. The Ladd & Tilton Bank, maybe the finest of the bunch, was pulled apart in 1954. Its iron front was saved and now dresses a bank in Salem.
What survives is still remarkable. Portland’s collection of cast-iron fronts is usually ranked second in the country, after New York’s SoHo. You can see the best of it in a ten minute walk around Skidmore/Old Town:
- The New Market Theater on SW 1st, with its arcade of freestanding columns next door.
- The Blagen Block on NW 1st and Couch.
- The Hallock-McMillan Building on SW Naito, from 1857, the oldest commercial building downtown.
- The Skidmore Fountain at the center of it all, under the Burnside Bridge.
Then look at the parking lots in between and do the math. With a little foresight Portland would have the largest cast-iron district in America, block after unbroken block of it. We have the pieces of one instead.
The Pattern
Line these five up and they rhyme. In every case something built for people on foot or on rails was traded for something built for cars: buses for trolleys, freeways for neighborhoods, parking for architecture. Even the river was treated as a convenient drain alongside a highway.
Portland eventually changed its mind on almost all of it. That is to the city’s credit. But changing your mind costs a great deal more than getting it right the first time, and a few of these we do not get back at any price.
- portland
- history
- streetcars
- lost-portland