The Most Ridiculous Intersection in Portland
Sandy Boulevard cuts across the grid at an angle and ruins every corner it touches. One of them, at NE 57th and Alameda, was in a class of its own.
People here will argue about the worst street in town the way people elsewhere argue about barbecue. Everyone has a candidate. Everyone is certain. The onramp that merges from the left, the bridgehead where three lanes become one without warning, the hill street that stops being a street partway up and becomes a staircase.
There is a reason the list is so long. Portland values its past, at least the parts it has not already torn down, and one side effect is that the odd decisions of early road builders never got bulldozed into six lane arterials and ten lane intersections. Add hills, gulches, and a river, and you get neighborhoods where driving is a real test of nerve.
The most frightened I have ever been behind the wheel in a big city was the day I got lost on the way to Council Crest Park. I ended up on streets so narrow and so steep that they seem to cling to the West Hills only because gravity has not quite got around to them yet.
But frightened is not the same as baffled. For baffled, I have one clear winner.
Sandy, 57th, and a third street nobody mentions
For about three months my commute ran through the intersection of NE Sandy Boulevard and NE 57th Avenue. That description is misleading, because it leaves out NE Alameda Street, which arrived at the same spot from its own angle.
Count the approaches: Sandy from two directions, 57th from two, Alameda from one. Five lines of cars. Five stop signs. No signal. And as a bonus, another junction just a short way farther up Sandy, close enough that cars leaving one were already tangled in the other.
A five way stop on a busy boulevard. Somebody approved that.
Blame the diagonal
Like most older cities, Portland has a handful of routes that predate the grid. They were roads to somewhere before there were blocks to go around, and they slice across the tidy squares at an angle.
Sandy Boulevard is the classic case. It is the old way from Portland out to the Sandy River, hence the name, and it was carrying wagons before Northeast Portland was much more than farms and stumps. When the neighborhoods filled in, the surveyors laid their numbered avenues and named streets straight over it. Every place the grid meets Sandy, you get a wedge shaped block, a flatiron building if you are lucky, and an intersection with at least one more leg than it ought to have.
Alameda complicates things further. It wanders along the ridge that bears its name instead of following the compass, so it meets other streets wherever the hill tells it to.
The rite of passage at 12th
The most famous Sandy tangle was at the other end, where Sandy met East Burnside and 12th. Anyone who drove in Portland before the Burnside and Couch couplet went in, around the start of the 2010s, remembers it. Six directions, odd angles, a signal cycle long enough to read a chapter. Getting through it without a horn aimed at you was a civic initiation.
How a five way stop actually works
It does not.
An ordinary four way stop in this city is already trying. You have two kinds of driver. The first is the super polite, passive type who waves everyone else through, including people who arrived well after them, and then waves again when nobody moves. The second is the usual lead foot who treats a stop sign as a suggestion. Put one of each at a corner and you get a standoff or a near miss.
Now add a fifth line of cars. The mental arithmetic of who got there first, hard enough with four, collapses entirely. Was the Alameda car before the 57th car? Does the Sandy driver even know Alameda exists? The tenuous arrangement slides into plain anarchy.
What you did, eventually, was this:
- Stop, roughly.
- Look at four other drivers, all of whom are looking at you.
- Wait for someone to go. Nobody goes.
- Hit the gas.
- Discover that at least one other driver chose the same moment.
- Negotiate in the middle of the intersection, on the fly, with eyebrows.
It was as much fun as it sounds. I did it twice a day.
What I guessed, and what happened
When I first wrote about this corner, the city had already found an answer for Burnside, 12th and Sandy, but nothing seemed to be planned for 57th, even though it sat on the edge of an urban renewal district. My amateur guess was that any fix would mean getting Alameda out of the intersection and putting signals on the other two streets.
I am pleased to report I was at least half right. A reader who drives it every day wrote in to say the stop signs are gone, there are traffic lights there now, and it is simply not an issue any longer. You wait for green, you go, nobody has to make eye contact. By that account it is now a perfectly ordinary Northeast Portland intersection, slightly crooked, entirely sane.
I admit to a small, unreasonable sense of loss. That is the local disease: complain about a thing for years, then miss it the moment it is fixed. But only a small one. Nobody sensible mourns a five way stop.
Your nominations
Sandy still has plenty of awkward corners left, and the West Hills have not gotten any wider. I know there are worse streets out there than the ones I have driven. So, the standing question: what is your pick for the most ridiculous intersection in Portland?
- portland
- sandy boulevard
- northeast portland
- streets
- traffic
- alameda
- burnside
- city history